top of page
Home: About Us

“The first step is to remind our students and colleagues that those who hold views contrary to one’s own are rarely evil or stupid, and may know or understand things that we do not. It is only when we start with this assumption that rational discourse can begin, and that the winds of freedom can blow." – Former Stanford Provost John Etchemendy

FEATURED ITEMS

​

 

Vanderbilt's Declaration of First Principles -- The University and Its Purpose 

​

Report of the Yale Committee on Trust in Higher Education

​

Restoring the Academic Social Contract

-- Stanford alum and U Texas-Austin Provost William Inboden

​​​

Guiding Principles -- Stanford President Jon Levin and Provost Jenny Martinez

 

​

​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​

From Our Latest Newsletter​

​

"To Be True To The Best You Know" -- Jane Stanford

November 16, 2026

​

A Different Approach for College Rankings

 

Editor’s note: College rankings, like political polls, are subject to the assumptions made by the organizers, risks with the data that are used, etc. So college rankings need to be read with that in mind, although when several are considered together, a more accurate picture can emerge.

 

That said, City Journal has published a ranking of U.S. colleges and universities using criteria different from what typically are used. A detailed explanation of the methodology is here, including: 

 

“Our rankings combine publicly available information from sources such as the Integrated Postsecondary Education Data System (IPEDS), the Department of Education’s College Scorecard, the American Council of Trustees and Alumni, and the Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression. We also developed a range of original measures exclusively for this project, including the ideological balance of student political organizations, the strength of a school’s mandated diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) course requirements, and the average political ideology of faculty and administrators who make campaign contributions. Some of these original measures allow us to assess schools on dimensions not covered in last year’s rankings. For example, our Presidential Reform Leadership Index tracks the extent to which college and university presidents publicly advocate for meritocracy, institutional neutrality, viewpoint diversity, and academic rigor.” 

 

A list of 115 schools, including more granular scores for each school, is at City Journal including these top 19:

 

  1. Texas at Austin

  2. Florida

  3. Notre Dame

  4. MIT

  5. Claremont McKenna

  6. UNC at Chapel Hill

  7. Georgia Tech

  8. Purdue

  9. Ohio State

  10. Yale

  11. Florida State

  12. Texas A&M

  13. Arizona State

  14. Vanderbilt

  15. Princeton

  16. Stanford

  17. Clemson

  18. Caltech

  19. Columbia and Harvard (tied)

 

See also “What Are Students Really Getting from College?” at Minding the Campus and with an interview of Cal State Prof. Kevin Wallsten discussing the City Journal rankings at YouTube (37 minutes).

 

Excerpt from the City Journal’s write-up re Stanford (although readers are encouraged to read the entire discussion about Stanford here): 

. . . . 

“Stanford’s president, Jonathan Levin, has emerged as a vocal advocate for higher education reform. In his September 2024 inaugural address, Levin declared that the university’s purpose was ‘not political action or social justice,’ but rather to foster learning and open inquiry. He has also acknowledged Stanford’s past failures to protect unpopular speech and called on universities to address legitimate public criticism. His statements earn Stanford sixth place in our rankings for presidential leadership.

 

“Still, Stanford has a record of putting demographic diversity ahead of merit. The university filed a brief supporting affirmative action in the Students for Fair Admissions case before the Supreme Court, and its faculty job advertisements continue to solicit diversity statements or impose similar requirements, underscoring its disregard for meritocratic principles. In June 2024, however, Stanford announced that it would reinstate standardized testing requirements for undergraduates entering in fall 2026.

 

“In early 2025, the university began removing explicitly ideological materials from its websites before cutting DEI programming. Still, Stanford retains a substantial administrative infrastructure, including its Office of Inclusion, Community and Integrative Learning, which professes ‘an institutional focus on equity, inclusion, and belonging’ and oversees the Centers for Equity, Community, and Leadership, whose mission is ‘grounded in values of justice.’ These student identity centers are staffed with 12.4 employees per 1,000 undergraduates -- the highest rate in our rankings, at about 8.3 times the overall average.” ...

 

[Followed by discussion of foreign influences, ideological diversity, the handling of controversial issues, student organizations, the curriculum, academic outcomes and economic outcomes.]

 

My University Had a Watch List; It Wasn’t Alone

 

Excerpts:

 

“Some years ago, a young staff member who handled social media for the university came to me with a problem.... The monitoring went well beyond university accounts. He told me his office tracked the personal social media of students, including locked accounts and private group chats, and sometimes recruited students to friend other students and pass along screenshots of whatever appeared behind the privacy settings....

 

“Universities have also been buying tools to automate online monitoring for years. A 2022 investigation by The Dallas Morning News and UC Berkeley’s Investigative Reporting Program found that at least 37 colleges had used Social Sentinel, software that’s marketed as a way to identify threats and students at risk of hurting themselves or others. But in practice, universities used it in much more intrusive ways. Kennesaw State campus police used Social Sentinel to track protesters before a town hall with a U.S. senator. UNC-Chapel Hill used it during demonstrations over a Confederate monument. The company also gave clients the ability to upload lists of individual Twitter accounts they wanted watched....

 

“I doubt many universities ever hold a meeting where someone proposes creating a surveillance apparatus. It probably starts with something reasonable: keeping an eye out for threats or students who may harm themselves.

 

“One office begins monitoring a few accounts. Another buys software. Someone creates a reporting form. Information gets retained because it might be useful later. Each step can be justified on its own. Years later, the university is monitoring people and collecting information in ways that would have sounded unthinkable if anyone had proposed the whole system at once.” ...

 

Full op-ed at Faculty Leaks. 

 

See also: “Stanford’s Computerized Case Management System for Student Behavior,” “Stanford’s Program re Bias,” and “Stanford's Now Discredited List of Words and Phrases” at our Stanford Concerns webpage and all as developed and/or maintained by Stanford’s IT department.

  

See also Stanford’s webpage re its surveillance cameras, as also installed by Stanford's IT department, as well as these recent articles at Stanford Daily and Stanford Review.

 

See also paragraphs 2.i., j. and k. at our Back to Basics webpage suggesting that students should be notified in writing at least annually of their FERPA rights to inspect all files created or maintained at Stanford about them. See also Stanford's FERPA website.

 

Other Articles of Interest

 

Update re University Endowments

 

A reader has pointed out that although the list of the top university endowments that we published in last week’s Newsletter was from a November 2, 2026 article at U.S. News, a Google/Gemini search provides this more current data:

 

  1. Harvard: $68.0 billion

  2. Stanford: $61.5 billion

  3. Yale: $53.3 billion

  4. Princeton: $42.3 billion

  5. Penn: $31.1 billion

  6. MIT: $27.4 billion 

  7. U Texas System: $27.2 billion

  8. Texas A&M System: $22.2 billion

  9. Michigan: $21.2 billion

  10. UC Systems: $20.2 billion

  11. Notre Dame: $20.1 billion

  12. WashU: $17.7 billion

 

Harvard Is Trying to Win Back Trust, and Professors Say It’s Working

 

Full article at NY Post: “Over the past several years, Harvard has fought to win back trust with all manner of policies aimed at protecting academic freedom, fighting grade inflation, promoting dialogue, making learning AI-resistant, and re-centering academics in campus life. According to professors on the ground, it’s actually working.”

​

See also “How Students Led a Push to Improve Harvard’s Intellectual Climate” at Harvard Alumni for Free Speech website.

 

Racial Separateness at Stanford

 

Full article at Stanford Review: “The Review’s investigation into institutionalized racial segregation at Stanford has documented a network of race-based institutions, accounts of prejudice within them, and patterns of student self-segregation. Our findings suggest that Stanford’s diversity efforts have deepened racial divisions rather than bridged them, raising serious questions about the university’s compliance with civil rights law.” Followed by detailed discussion of race-based clubs, residences, centers, fees, commencement activities and related matters.

 

Study Finds the Biggest Academic Problem for College Students Isn't Stress or Anxiety, It’s Procrastination

 

Full article at Science Alert: “In a new study in PLOS One, social scientist Itamar Shatz from the University of Cambridge analyzed survey responses from over 65,000 college students at almost 100 academic institutions across the US.... Students indicated the biggest issue causing problems with their academic performance was procrastination, with 45.4 percent of the survey respondents saying procrastination affected their academic results, followed by stress (36.6 percent), anxiety (30.4 percent), sleep difficulties (22 percent), and depression (20 percent).”

 

You Are Protesting the Wrong Technology

 

Full op-ed by Utah Prof. Hollis Robbins at Substack: “To the faculty who have been organizing against AI: you are fighting the wrong technology. While you’re writing think pieces about ‘cognitive offloading’ and ‘the importance of writing’ on social media, you’re still using Canvas, Brightspace, and Blackboard to ‘deliver instruction’ to your students.... What is wrong with you people? Canvas is a far more dangerous and corrupting technology than AI. Want evidence? Here you go.” [Followed by a detailed discussion of concerns. Note that Canvas is the primary Cloud-Based Learning Management System used at Stanford; see also Academic Technology Tools at Stanford.]

 

Colleges Are Teaching Generations of Students to Distrust America's History and Institutions Without First Understanding What Made Them Worth Defending

 

Full op-ed at James Martin Center: “Traditional history placed events in sequence and context. Political, military, economic, religious, and cultural developments were studied together. In contrast, today’s specialized studies programs replace a coherent civilizational narrative with identity-defined fields organized around race, sexuality, colonialism, and power.” With specific examples at Harvard and elsewhere.

 

College Is About More Than a Paycheck

 

Full article at EDU Ledger.

 

Stanford Plans to Build 8-Story Housing Complex at Research Park

 

Full article at Palo Alto Online.

 

Why We Care -- Samples of Current Teaching, Research and Other Activities at Stanford

 

Click on each article for direct access; selections are from Stanford Report and other Stanford websites.

 

“Disagree with a Professor” Invites Students to Take Up Provocative Ideas with Stanford Faculty in an Informal, Low-Stakes Setting

 

Brain Activity Patterns May Predict Alzheimer’s Years Before Memory Slips

 

Has AI Really Changed Math Forever?

 

**********​​​​​​​

“When scholars and students engage with people who think differently -- across moral, cultural, and theoretical lines -- they encounter new evidence, question assumptions, and sharpen their own reasoning. The most vibrant universities are not echo chambers dominated by groupthink, but arenas where ideas are tested, refined, and replaced.” – From Heterodox Academy

Comments and Questions from Our Readers

See more reader comments on our Reader Comments webpage.

Need Dialog, Not Prohibitions

​

I suggest the university produce forums in which ultimate concerns about war and peace presently unfolding be formally debated, subject to the rules of decorum. This is what the university is for, not prohibitions on argument or advocacy. Silence renders learning impossible. 

Hoping for Balanced Speech at Stanford

​

I am so in support of the opinions expressed here and hope Stanford will adopt a more balanced approach to free speech. I can only hope.

 

Teaching Young People and Others How to Disagree Civilly

​

While I believe that supporting free speech is very important in and of itself, I also believe that there is a related component that is often ignored. That component is teaching people, especially young people, how to disagree civilly/how to constructively respond to free speech they might not agree with.

Question About Ties to the Alumni Association

​

Q.  I notice that the SAA website contains no links to the Stanford Alumni for Free Speech and Critical Thinking website. Why is that?

 

A. Our website is not linked at the SAA website since we intentionally did not seek to become an affiliate of SAA. Among other things, we wanted to maintain independence, including since SAA became a subsidiary of 

the university in the mid-1990’s. That said, there are a number of current and former Stanford administrators and trustees who receive our Newsletters and read the materials that are posted at the website.

About Us

Member, Alumni Free Speech Alliance

 

Stanford Alumni for Free Speech and Critical Thinking is an independent, diverse, and nonpartisan group of Stanford alumni committed to promoting and safeguarding freedom of thought and expression, intellectual diversity and inclusion, and academic freedom at Stanford.

​

We believe innovation and positive change for the common good is achieved through free and active discourse from varying viewpoints, the freedom to question both popular and unpopular opinions, and the freedom to seek truth without fear of reprisal from those who disagree, within the confines of humanity and mutual respect.  

 

Our goal is to support students, faculty, administrators, and staff in efforts that assure the Stanford community is truly inclusive as to what can be said in and outside the classroom, the kinds of speakers that can be invited, and what should always be the core principles of a great university like Stanford.  We also advocate that Stanford incorporates the Chicago Trifecta, the gold standard for freedom of speech and expression at college and university campuses, and that Stanford abides by these principles in both its policies and its actions.  

​

bottom of page